Sunday morning in Williamsburg October 28, 2007
What a pleasure it is to be able to sleep late in the morning until my eyes just refuse to close again. That's the kind of morning it is today. After 11 hours of peaceful slumber my body feels awake and ready for a leisurely breakfast and a day of discovery.
Williamsburg, a place of mystique, charm and romance of the 18th century, calls to Americans to celebrate the great revolt. Called patriots today, the men of the mid-seventeen hundred's were young, passionate and astonishingly rebellious. Their passion for freedom lives in our hearts and minds today, a part of the fabric of our lives. What we now call patriotic was then treason. These men wanted to overthrow the government, after all, and not peacefully.
I came to look at Colonial Revival gardens. How extraordinarily tame! There are no stirrings of revolution in parterre's and alleés punctuated by intricate topiaries. But are they authentic? Landscape architects and garden historians debate that question.
My own vegetable garden was planned with the spirit of tamed orderliness I saw here. It was a delightful conceit, but so very impractical that in the end I left it to the wild. Somehow logic tells me that were I to return to the 1700's the element of wild disarray would be the standard in all but the gardens of the wealthy aristocracy. The governor's palace gardens were so expensive to build and maintain, after all, that Governor at one point threw up his hands in exasperation and frustration with the lack of money to keep them true to his vision.
Later:
Today my eyes, ears and mind were focused on learning to understand Colonial revival gardens. I saw that landscaping is dynamic. Plants keep on growing. They outgrow their spaces without ruthless pruning. In 1928 landscape architect Arthur A. Shurcliff was hired by Rockefeller to create in Colonial Williamsburg gardens as they might have looked in the 1700's. It became the standard for the Colonial Revival style. His interpretation was to copy what he felt the new settlers expected, something that would remind them of England not the wilderness around them. Yet, there is a sameness that I thought would not have existed because these settlers were becoming a new breed of people unfettered by tradition.
Fences all had unlocked swinging gates which I interpreted as an invitation to wander around. Kitchen gardens were downright neat and tidy, hardly typical in Virginia's long, hot, humid summers. There is an abundance of criss crossing pathways through the back yards, well ordered beds laid out geometrically, outlined by neatly trimmed boxwoods. All had centerpieces of either a sundial or an ornamental holly. In spring, so I have seen in pictures, the spaces will be filled with flowering bulbs.
Pastures with sheep placidly feeding were charming. The back yard pattern was a bricked work area immediately outside the back door, the parterre, an orchard, and either a kitchen garden or simply grass. There could be a pasture. The areas were separated by fences that often had shrubs planted in beds along their borders.
The large trees gave marvelous shade, but some were so old they obviously had serious problems. The great oak that had been a landmark at the former residence of the Rockefeller's, Basset Hall, had fallen to an ice storm a few years ago. Only the stump remains of this tree that had lasted about 400 years.
What an exhausting and yet satisfying day. Tourists are generally friendly and want to chat. The guides seem to really enjoy us. At Shields Tavern where I went for a ham biscuit breakfast, one of the interpretive guides shared his break time with me to tell me his slant on the current controversy over landscaping theory. His take on the matter was that mistakes had been made in interpretation. He said that tradesmen's homes probably had far more informal backyards than Shurcliff designed. Other tourists with whom I spoke thought it was better to leave things the way they were because it just looked orderly. Each point of view is just that. We can't really know what it was like because, as one tourist said, they didn't take any Polaroids.
I spent an hour talking with an older man who said he had lived in Williamsburg for a year when he was on Sabbatical from Purdue University. We sat for awhile under the shade of the mulberry trees that line a street leading to Scotland Street from the capitol building. The mulberries are ancient and gnarled with their huge limbs spread like the palms of outstretched hands, fingers nearly brushing the ground. He claimed they were from the time of Pocahontas. It was breezy and rather chilly in the shade so we moved on to a garden next to Shield's where he identified the variety of bay shrubs he claimed he had dug up from a swampy area near the home where he had stayed for a year. The leaves were pleasantly aromatic. His name was Bob Hawley and he lives in Ft. Wayne, Indiana. I guess that is far enough away to make our conversation quite safe. He said he was a professor emeritus of behavioral psychology, a fact not verified by my later Internet search. Not everything he told me made sense, but it's of no matter. It was a pleasant hour of rest for my feet.
My day ended watching the costumed staff provide entertainment for the tourists in Duke of Gloucester Street in front of Kings Arms Tavern where I had supper. Taking advantage of several choices on the menu that evoked what the patriots of the 18th century might have enjoyed, it was a good meal. We had two people entertain as as we ate, one a performer who told tales of her life as a young mother in Williamsburg and the other a sprightly fiddler who played both Irish and Scottish tunes that had our feet tapping in time.
With tired feet I slept well and long.
Monday, on my continuing quest for knowledge about Colonial Revival gardens, I stopped to chat with two gardeners in colonial garb today on Duke of Gloucester Street. One turned out to be a garden historian, Wesley Greene. He was pleased to give me his opinion of the current controversy and summed it up with, “There are too many boxwoods and too few chickens.” There are no chickens.
Wesley said that he felt it unlikely that there were many kitchen gardens anyway because they are labor intensive, especially in the summer when the traditional July drought occurs. Colonial people were not overly concerned with getting their veggies anyway. Their diet was heavy in meat, both domestic and wild. The result was that many of them suffered from gout.
Apparently George Washington did recognize that some wild greens would protect his troops from scurvy. He sent men out into the woods around Valley Forge during that terrible winter to find edible shoots of various plants that would protect the men from that fatal disease. History tells us that there was little to eat anyway during that awful encampment.
Bill Krebs, master gardener volunteer stood back and let Wesley have the stage. I noticed that and I also noted that Bill was not doing much so far as gardening went other than picking bouquets of globe amaranth. I asked about some plants after Wesley had finished his explanations. Bill told a great story about a culinary disaster with one of the plants which turned out to be edible, but tasted like deep fried stringy celery! What a sense of humor.
Honestly, I learned more from this discussion than I did on the garden tour that I hurried on to join. I did meet the director of gardeners, Laura Viancour. She told me there are 40 Master Gardeners who volunteer to keep everything watered, weeded and pruned. Two of the Master Gardeners joined us and actually gave the tour. It was amazing that there is a paperbark mulberry here that has a fungus called the “red rot” which has a symbiotic relationship with the tree. The fungus hollows out the trunk and branches, but the tree does not die.
Following the tour I was famished and sat down outdoors under an arbor to have a tasty pulled pork barbecue, slaw and an Old Dominion lager. I went back to my residence and fell asleep for the rest of the afternoon.
Monday night I enjoyed the Legends ghost walk. There were no ghosts, but the story tellers legends were most entertaining. Chilled through in the night air, I returned for a hot tub and more sleep. Walking about in the streets of Colonial Williamsburg guarantees a night of peaceful slumber.
Tuesday was my last day here following my visit to the Governor's Palace gardens. Because of doing my homework the palace grounds were far more interesting. The very English gardens were not out of place here. Everything was orderly from the parterres with their huge cylinders of trimmed boxwood called “The Twelve Apostles” to the canal. I climbed the Mount to view the Maze, then clambered down very carefully to peer into the ice house under the Mount. I gazed in wonder at the two American beech alleés, branches of which had been pleached or braided together to form a dense archway. The palace garden included an orchard of cordoned fruit trees and espaliered apricots and nectarines. There were small green figs on the fig trees and ripe pomegranates shining red from the branches not low enough for tourists to pluck them. I walked completely around the canal and left by climbing the stairs up the falling gardens which were now turf terraces. Lastly, I gazed through breaks in the hedge to see the Revolutionary War cemetery in which 157 people are buried in unmarked graves. They died in the palace hospital after the battle of Yorktown.
I went home afterwards, cold, tired and completely satisfied.
